skip to content
Replays

Modal Overlay Rework

Shared Modals for the TUI

Gantry rebuilt its dialog overlays on one modal path and made dismissed modal events reopenable.

Gantry milestones

3 milestones 14 tasks 32 agents

8 plan 12 execute 18 review

203k peak context

151k median execute

Gantry rebuilt its dialog overlays on one modal path and made dismissed modal events reopenable.

2h 55m total 12m 23s per task

7m 3s plan 1h 24m execute 44m 44s review

141 edits 1.1k commands

codex harness

This run rebuilt Gantry's terminal dialogs from the library layer up through the application overlays. The work started by refreshing the vendored modal system, then moved every dialog-shaped surface onto the shared path, repaired global-key fallthrough around parent overlays, and finished by teaching Recent events to reopen stored modal payloads.

The decomposition was not just mechanical migration. Review found a swallowed global-help key after the foundation milestone and a recovery-action ordering regression after the broad overlay migration, so later milestones carried those corrections forward instead of treating the earlier green rows as enough. In the current tree, the shared modal layer, recovery action contract, and reopenable Recent events payloads are still visible in the TUI code and vendored modal crate.

How this walkthrough is structured

Feature

What did the run build and ship?

Gantry now has a shared modal path for dialog-shaped overlays, bounded scrollable modal bodies, repaired global-key fallthrough, recovery actions led by external harnesses, and Recent events entries that can reopen modal content.

Build

How did Gantry structure the work?

The run cut a wide TUI rework into a vendored foundation, a full overlay migration, and a modal-history finish, with milestone reviews feeding the two unfinished contracts into the next slice.

Milestone 1

Modal Foundation

3 tasks 9 agents 37m 22s wall time 186k peak context

The foundation still stands in the vendored modal crate and in Gantry's application-side modal module. The current tree exposes shared descriptions, button rows, text input rows, scrollable body state, modal chrome, and explicit unhandled-key results. The representative migration has since been joined by broader overlay work, so its individual user surface is no longer the main evidence; the reusable contract is.

This milestone carried the prerequisite layer and only one representative Gantry migration. That made the work small enough for fresh agents: refresh the vendored crate, wrap it in a Gantry-owned contract, and prove the path on a real non-text modal. The child sprints stayed green, but milestone review found that the outer overlay shortcut layer could still intercept a key before shared modal dispatch saw it. That became explicit input for the next milestone rather than hidden debt.

Vendored Modal Refresh

2 agents 9m 20s wall time 96k peak context

The vendored crate still contains the modal layout system this sprint brought in. It has content-driven sizing, scrollable text surfaces, action button rows with opaque action strings, modal chrome, and key results that distinguish handled input from host-owned input. The examples and tests around modal dialogs remain in the vendored tree as evidence of that library surface.

This sprint was the external base for everything that followed. Its brief kept the agent on vendoring discipline: refresh the snapshot, keep the lockfile consistent, carry tests and examples, and only add missing behavior in application-neutral terms. It passed cleanly, so later Gantry-side sprints could rely on the library contract rather than rediscover modal layout primitives.

Shared Modal Contract

2 agents 7m 38s wall time 124k peak context

Gantry's shared modal module is still the application boundary. Callers describe titles, bodies, form rows, button actions, usage text, and optional text input, then render and dispatch through the same modal object. That code keeps library details out of individual overlays while preserving the host-level not-handled result that global bindings depend on.

This sprint translated the refreshed library API into Gantry's own boundary. The task was deliberately not a migration sweep; it was to define the shape later overlays would consume so they stopped owning sizing, chrome, button rendering, and unconditional key swallowing. Its gate stayed green, giving the next sprint a stable application contract to try against real TUI behavior.

Representative Modal Migration

2 agents 13m 31s wall time 186k peak context

The representative path is now absorbed into the shared modal system used by many overlays. Its lasting contribution is not a separate dialog but the evidence that Gantry-owned modal descriptions could preserve user behavior while removing bespoke rendering. Current prompt, info, help, pager, and Recent events code all consume the same pattern that this sprint validated.

This sprint proved the new contract on a real non-text dialog without taking on the full overlay catalog. The brief asked for enough behavior to exercise body layout, scrolling, buttons, chrome, and host key fallthrough. It passed inside the milestone, but the later milestone review showed that proving one call site was not the same as proving every parent overlay dispatch path.

Milestone 2

Overlay Migration

7 tasks 16 agents 1h 41m wall time 203k peak context

Most dialog-shaped TUI overlays now route through the shared modal integration instead of owning separate chrome and key paths. The current render and input code still documents the deliberate boundary for full-screen stats and git activity panes while their dialog-shaped drill targets use modal chrome. That leaves a clearer split between modal dialogs and whole-body panes than the old mixed overlay code had.

This milestone was the main migration slab. It started by repairing the shortcut layer exposed by the foundation review, then moved recovery prompts, engine prompts, stop-class dialogs, read-only overlays, pagers, and cleanup through the shared contract. The nested sprint gates were green, but milestone review found the recovery action order had been encoded wrong, so the final milestone had to repair that contract before building modal history on it.

Overlay Dispatch Repair

2 agents 3m 38s wall time 97k peak context

The input dispatcher still routes unclaimed keys from shared modals to global handling before parent overlay shortcuts can consume them. Read-only Recent events snapshots, help, info, confirmations, and other modal surfaces use the same pattern: modal-owned keys stay local, while help, quit, and menu-style keys can reach the application. Tests in the TUI cover the reopened-modal version of that same guarantee.

This sprint came first because every later migrated overlay depended on host-level fallthrough being real. The agent did not have to move more surfaces yet; it only had to repair the path from a frontmost shared modal through parent overlay shortcuts into global bindings. It passed cleanly, turning the foundation review's concrete swallowed-help case into a contract later sprints could consume.

Recovery Contract Setup

2 agents 11m 31s wall time 203k peak context

The current domain and run-engine tests now assert the recovery contract directly across prompt producers. External harness choices lead the list, the internal Gantry action is still available but demoted, shell remains a launcher, and stop remains resolving. Because the final repair changed the contract after this sprint, this row's feature is best understood as the initial shared surface that later got corrected.

This sprint isolated recovery action semantics before modal chrome touched every blocker-class surface. Its scope was intentionally independent of layout: define the order, focus, no-external message, and opaque action tokens once so later prompts could reuse them. The sprint itself went green, but the milestone review later found the order was still wrong in the composed result, which limited how much final confidence this row could carry.

Engine Prompt Migration

2 agents 18m 38s wall time 121k peak context 1 replan

Engine-raised prompts now build shared modal descriptions and keep their answer semantics outside the renderer. Text prompts keep focused input, fixed-choice prompts emit opaque choice tokens, confirmations keep safe defaults, and blocker prompts reuse recovery buttons. The current state code still constructs prompt modals from PromptNeeded events and answers through the same prompt-answer channel.

This sprint moved the highest-value prompt family after fallthrough and recovery contracts existed. Its brief covered text prompts, confirmations, fixed choices, and blocker investigation prompts while preserving the engine's prompt-answer wait. The run facts show a replan stage in this area, which fits a migration that had to compose prompt semantics with the newly repaired modal route rather than just repaint a dialog.

Stop and Confirm Migration

2 agents 15m 15s wall time 151k peak context

Stop and pause events are modal-worthy in the current Recent events model, and local confirmations render through the shared modal chrome. Stop-class bodies can be stored for later read-only reopening, while live blocker-class surfaces still use recovery choices from the shared contract. The older build files named by the git facts have since moved under the run engine, but the behavior remains in the current prompt and TUI state paths.

This sprint carried stop, halt, error, and local confirmation surfaces after engine prompts had proven the core prompt path. The cut kept the worker focused on stop-class decisions and status bodies: shared sizing, scrollable reports, recovery ordering, and preserved local confirmation behavior. It stayed green, so the read-only migrations could proceed without reopening stop semantics.

Read-Only Dialog Migration

1 agents 19m 38s wall time 103k peak context

Read-only dialog helpers still build shared modal descriptions with scrollable bodies and usage text. Help and info overlays sit on the same modal tier as the rest of the dialog stack, and selected body text is registered for overlay selection where the TUI supports it. Their individual old chrome helpers are no longer the primary rendering path.

This sprint grouped the smaller read-only dialogs so a fresh agent could remove a cluster of bespoke panel math without also solving pager boundaries. Help, info, and session-style content all needed shared overflow behavior and the repaired global-key path. The row stayed green, which left the richer pager audit as a separate problem.

Pager Boundary Review

2 agents 12m 52s wall time 201k peak context

The current renderer still carries the run-record notes from this decision. Stats and git activity remain whole-body overlays because they are navigable, repainting panes, while shared pagers and drill targets render above them as modal surfaces. The pager keeps search, movement, highlighting, follow mode, and empty-state behavior while using shared modal layering where it is dialog-shaped.

This sprint handled the ambiguous read-only surfaces after simpler dialogs had moved. Its brief asked the agent to migrate modal-shaped pager presentations while recording which overlays were genuinely whole-body panes. That made the boundary review explicit: stats and git activity could stay panes, while their dialog-shaped drill and pager targets had to obey the shared modal contract.

Legacy Modal Cleanup

2 agents 13m 46s wall time 168k peak context

The TUI no longer depends on a separate old modal renderer for the migrated families. Shared modal descriptions, scrollable bodies, button rows, and fallthrough dispatch are the surviving mechanisms, while full-screen panes are documented as intentional exceptions. The regression suite now spans the modal guarantees instead of only testing isolated helpers.

This cleanup sprint came last because deleting old modal behavior is only safe once every migrated family has a shared replacement. Its gate ran more than once but stayed green, which marks the cleanup as broad rather than architecturally blocked. The later milestone review still caught recovery ordering outside this cleanup's declared scope, so this row closes legacy rendering paths rather than the entire plan.

Milestone 3

Reopenable Events

4 tasks 13 agents 57m 14s wall time 197k peak context

Recent events now carries bounded modal snapshots for prompt and stop content, and selecting a modal-bearing entry can reopen the content through shared modal chrome. Resolved and historic entries reopen read-only, while still-pending prompts refocus or answer through the live prompt path. The code also caps large bodies with a visible truncation marker so the menu projection does not become an unbounded transcript cache.

This milestone finished the plan by making dismissed modal content returnable from Recent events, but it first had to repair the recovery order that the previous review rejected. The first child sprint was retried through a replan, placing the hard boundary exactly where the run record says it was: blocker-class recovery had to be trustworthy before historic modal entries could reuse it. The remaining payload, reopen, and regression sprints then ran cleanly.

Recovery Contract Repair

5 agents 22m 23s wall time 129k peak context 1 replan

The repaired contract is visible in the domain helper and in run-engine tests that construct real prompt producer paths. External harness actions are preferred and default-focused when available; the internal Gantry action follows them and stays ahead of shell and stop actions. The tests are written to fail if shell moves ahead of the demoted internal action again.

This sprint was the run's only recorded recovery. The first attempt did not settle the blocker-class order strongly enough, review noted it, and Gantry replanned this exact sprint before the milestone continued. That makes the boundary clear: modal history could not build on blocker, halt, and error prompts until their producers, buttons, focus, and tests all agreed on one action contract.

Persist Modal Payloads

2 agents 9m 44s wall time 120k peak context

The current TUI state has a ReopenableModalPayload with title, body, category, truncation status, and optional prompt metadata. Prompt snapshots distinguish pending, historic, and resolved states, and pending entries keep choice actions from the underlying prompt. Large bodies are capped with a visible marker, and ordinary non-modal recent entries keep their card-jump behavior.

This sprint created the data contract for reopening without touching the rendering workflow yet. The brief kept the work bounded to Recent events: store display-ready modal content, prompt identity, liveness, truncation state, and current choice tokens while preserving the existing bounded feed. It passed cleanly because the reopen decision and UI flow were left for the next slice.

Reopen Recent Modals

2 agents 11m 54s wall time 197k peak context

Selecting a modal-bearing Recent events row now reopens the modal content. If the stored prompt is still answerable and live, the existing prompt modal is refocused so answering uses the original engine channel; otherwise a read-only Recent events modal opens with shared scrolling and close behavior. Repeated dismiss and reopen does not duplicate recent entries or lose prompt state.

This sprint turned the stored payload into the user workflow. It could stay focused because the previous sprint had already defined the snapshot contract and the first sprint had repaired recovery choices. Its job was to route selection from Recent events either back to a live prompt or into a read-only modal, while preserving feed selection for entries that are not modal content.

Modal Regression Sweep

1 agents 6m 20s wall time 67k peak context

The current tests cover live and reopened modal behavior together. Reopened bodies scroll to hidden content, unclaimed keys from reopened non-text modals fall through to global help or quit before parent shortcuts, and recovery buttons keep external harnesses ahead of the demoted internal action. Those tests are the standing guard for the failures this run was built to remove.

This final sprint was verification, not a new modal system. It consumed the repaired recovery contract and the reopenable payload contract, then checked the original complaints across live and reopened paths. It stayed green, closing the run with focused regression coverage for clipped text, swallowed global keys, and wrong blocker recovery ordering.